Helen Keller Writes a Letter to Nazi College students Earlier than They Burn Her Guide: “Historical past Has Taught You Nothing If You Suppose You Can Kill Concepts” (1933)

Helen Keller achieved notoriety not solely as a person success story, but in addition as a prolific essayist, activist, and fierce advocate for poor and marginalized individuals. She “was a lifelong radical,” writes Peter Dreier at Sure! journal, whose “investigation into the causes of blindness” finally led her to “embrace socialism, feminism, and pacifism.” Keller supported the NAACP and ACLU, and protested strongly towards patronizing requires her to “confine my actions to social service and the blind.” Her critics, she wrote, mischaracterized her concepts as “a Utopian dream, and one who significantly contemplates its realization certainly should be deaf, dumb, and blind.”

Twenty years later she discovered a distinct set of readers treating her concepts with contempt. This time, nevertheless, the critics had been in Nazi Germany, and as an alternative of merely disagreeing along with her, they added her assortment of essays, How I Grew to become a Socialist, to a checklist of “degenerate” books to be burned on Might 10, 1933. Such was the date chosen by Hitler for “a nationwide ‘Motion Towards the Un-German Spirit,’” writes Rafael Medoff, to happen at German Universities—“a sequence of public burnings of the banned books” that “differed from the Nazis’ perspective on political, social, or cultural issues, in addition to all books by Jewish authors.”

Books burned included works by Einstein and Freud, H.G. Wells, Hemingway, and Jack London, College students hauled books out of the libraries as a part of the spectacle. “The biggest of the 34 book-burning rallies, held in Berlin,” Medoff notes, “was attended by an estimated 40,000 individuals.”

Not solely had been these demonstrations of anti-Semitism, however their contempt for concepts appealed broadly to the Nazi philosophy of “Blood and Soil,” a nationalist caricature of rural values over a supposedly “degenerate,” polyglot urbanism. “The soul of the German individuals can once more categorical itself,” declared Joseph Goebbels ominously on the Berlin rally. “These flames not solely illuminate the ultimate finish of an outdated period; in addition they gentle up the brand new.”

“Some American editorial responses” earlier than and after the burnings, “made gentle of the occasion,” remarks the United States Holocaust Museum, calling it “foolish” and “childish.”  Others foresaw a lot worse to return. In a single very express expression of the horrible potentialities, artist and political cartoonist Jacob Burck drew the picture above, evoking the commentary of nineteenth century German author Heinrich Heine: “The place one burns books, one will quickly burn individuals.” Newsweek described the occasions as “’a holocaust of books’… one of many first cases wherein the time period ‘holocaust’ (an historical Greek phrase which means a burnt providing to a deity) was utilized in reference to the Nazis.”

The day earlier than the burnings, Keller additionally displayed a eager sense for the gravity of e-book burnings, in addition to a “notable… early concern,” notes Rebecca Onion at Slate—outdoors the Jewish group, that’s—for what she referred to as the “barbarities to the Jews.” On Might 9, 1933, Keller printed a brief however pointed open letter to the Nazi college students in The New York Occasions and elsewhere, abjuring them to cease the proposed burnings. She wrote in a spiritual idiom, invoking the “judgment” of God and paraphrasing the Bible. (Not a conventional Christian, she belonged to a mystical sect referred to as Swedenborgianism.) On the prime of the submit, you possibly can see the typescript of her letter, with corrections and annotations by Polly Thompson, one in all her major aides. Learn the complete transcript under:

Keller added the penultimate paragraph of the printed textual content later. (See the handwritten addition on the backside of the typed draft.) Her concern for the “grievous problems” of the German individuals was actually real. The expression additionally looks like a focused rhetorical transfer for a scholar viewers, conceding the scenario as “complicated,” and interesting in additional philosophical language to “justice” and “knowledge.” The Nazis ignored her protest, as they did the “huge road demonstrations” that occurred on the tenth “in dozens of American cities,” the Holocaust Museum writes, “skillfully organized by the American Jewish Congress” and sparking “the most important demonstration in New York Metropolis historical past as much as that date.”

5 years later, nevertheless, one other deliberate e-book burning—this time in Austria earlier than its annexation—was prevented by college students at Williams Faculty, Yale, and different universities within the U.S., the place pro- and anti-Nazi partisans fought one another on a number of American campuses. U.S. college students had been capable of push the Austrian Nationwide Library to lock the books away relatively than burn them. Keller “isn’t identified to have commented particularly” on these scholar protests, writes Medoff, “however one could assume she was deeply proud that at a time when too many Individuals didn’t wish to be bothered with Europe’s issues, these younger women and men understood the message of her 1933 letter—that the rules beneath assault by the Nazis had been one thing that ought to matter to all mankind.”

Notice: This submit initially appeared on our web site in 2017.

If you need to join Open Tradition’s free e mail publication, please discover it right here.

If you need to assist the mission of Open Tradition, contemplate making a donation to our web site. It’s laborious to rely 100% on advertisements, and your contributions will assist us proceed offering the perfect free cultural and academic supplies to learners all over the place. You may contribute via PayPal, Patreon, Venmo (@openculture) and Crypto. Thanks!